In theory usb3 should have a decent amount of bandwidth, in practice for whatever reason the caddy isnt much faster than usb2 and cannot handle random. Both software offerings are pretty much identical, so youll need to compare other features. Whereas synology dsm is more about ios design, qnap and qts are far more in the vein of android and windows. The sidebyside comparison of the devices specifications.
Synology blows qnap out of the water in terms of bakedin features and ease of use. If you are planning to use your nas device for hyperv or for backups, please read this article first before diving into further details. However, i decided on qnap which has a local australian site and estore, and is available pretty much everywhere where you can find synology. Nas singapore qnap synology network attached storage nas. With all the new solutions from synology, things can be complicated. Nas compares qnap ts230 vs synology ds220j nas best. Sign in to myqnapcloud to securely access your remote qnap devices, manage your nas from anywhere, and share files easily. This synology vs qnap guide will help you decide which is best to choose between. If you ever built a pc, or use an android device for its flexibility and individuality, then you will certainly vibe with the qnap nas software more. Contact us for assistance to find the right synology nas for your needs.
Not a huge fan of prebuilt nas devices any more, having worked for qnap and having one of their devices for a few years, as well as having used synology in the past. However, qnap units will transcode your plex media server more efficiently than synology device. Asustor, qnap, and synology introduce new nas units at ces 2020. Support for plex media player is one of the uppermost reasons why people buy network attached storages. At backupchain we have put together this article to describe some of the shortcomings of specific network attached storage devices, such as drobo, buffalo, synology, netgear, qnap, iomega, iosafe, diskstation, readynas, lets collectively call them l nas. Not to be a dick but if you want guaranteed support in a production environment, dont buy synology or qnap. I just bought my first synology a month ago after doing a lot of research between the two. For the software and user interface, i have had far less complaints with synology, where it just seems to work and is way more polished than qnap. The comparison table below makes it easier to choose the most fitting nas. Excellent support yes it does work as a time machine drive enable that in. Synology drive client, the desktop utility of the dsm addon package, synology drive server, allows you to sync and share files owned by you or shared by others between a centralized synology nas and multiple client computers.
Why you shouldnt buy a nas like drobo, synology, buffalo, netgear, qnap if you are planning to use your nas device for hyperv or for backups, please read this article first before diving into further details. Qnap is concentrating more on virtualization, while synology is focused on surveillance. On the software front, devices may have synology high availability, mailplus, virtual dsm, docker dsm, a btrfs file system or snapshot replication. More direct attached options and therefore software like kodi and plex via hdmi on a qnap. On the positive however, synology nas drives are cheaper than. And of course, being among the best, both synology and qnap come with support for plex media server.
Of course, you can still access a nas device the traditional way as a network drive and through an ip address from a windows, mac or linux. Ive used synology and theyre awesome, but not for production where you want a response in a guaranteed timeframe. Comparison of synology diskstation ds416j and qnap ts431. Qnaps comprehensive selection of nas solutions meets different consumer needs from small bay models designed for home users to tower and rackmount level nas for businesses and workgroups. I only use my nas for personal cloud, media storage and server, and the o occasional. Compare synology diskstation nas ds418 qnap desktop nas. In the area of video transcoding, five synology nas models are 4kequipped, with three of these coming from the plus series and the others from the value. I run four larger synology nas units holding 120 tb of data.
In this article, i will explain all the backup and cloud software the nas diskstation provide us. There is no support sla from qnap or synology support, so you could be down. Nas compares qnap ts230 vs synology ds220j nas best for. While both qnap and synology units support the traditional raid levels raid 0, raid 1 and raid 5, raid 6 and raid 10, but synology nas units support something called synology hybrid raid shr. Synology vs buffalo vs qnap data storage spiceworks.
However, the difference lies in the direction of their software development. For those looking for more quantitative differences, synology noted that it is the only nas manufacturer to offer expandable nases that connect to expansion units via highbandwidth dedicated interfaces qnaps primary focus is clearly on business users with a specific focus on virtualization. The desktop settinginterface of dsm os shares relatively high semblance with apples macos while qnap s qts os can be compared to windows or android. Excellent support yes it does work as a time machine drive enable that in the admin control panel. Do they have the packages and function that i need. Likewise, qnap has spent years refining their nas operating system with qnap turbo station, or qts. Sep 10, 2019 both synology and qnap units will arrive with their own desktop user interface packed in a proprietary operating system. Synology is much better with qc of their software and are generally always ahead of qnap in new feature esfunctionality after a few years of tinkering with my qnap, i realized everything i needed it to do came with prebuild packages from the community. If synology is mac, then qnap is most certainly windows and android.
Sep, 2018 qnaps qts and synologys dsm are two great software options for a nas. I went with a qnap personally, because i like to mess with things just because i can. Sep 28, 2018 it would give you an idea about how their software works. Qnap ts1685 vs synology ds3617xs battle of the nas behemoths. Ubuntu 32 bits, deb ubuntu 64 bits, deb synology chat client.
Qnap and synology are both excellent, and are the market leaders. Both manufacturers provide great software, albeit qnaps qts is more. Like the qnap software, synologys software is just as feature packed and theres simply way too much to cover in depth. Jun 15, 2017 more direct attached options and therefore software like kodi and plex via hdmi on a qnap.
Synology chat client is a featurerich desktop native. Straight away when you compare the specifications both in terms of hardware and software of a qnap nas versus a synology, you will immediately notice that you get much better cpus and ram options in. Qnap offers slightly better hardware for the same price. I need to rebuild my storage backend i use for emby and other things as its currently a usb3 multidrive caddy connected to a j1900 itx board the machine its connected to is also my emby server. Why you shouldnt buy a nas like drobo, synology, buffalo. Its highly recommended you try both their online nas demo software to ultimately help you decide which nas software you could live with, or which you would rather live without. When i originally looked into a nas device, i picked the qnap. Whether this is because of emptier wallets or because of the 24. Although there are many expensive or overpowered nas drives out there, there is still a big demand for low end and modestly powered network. One thing is certain, both synology and qnap make some of the best quality nas boxes available today. Comparison of synology diskstation ds416play and qnap ts. The choice then was similar a qnap one of just about identical specs and price. Discussion in nas systems and networked home and smb software started by msvirtualguy, jun 15, 2017.
At the time the synology was quite a bit faster 50% or so in real world tests. Synology has a network only stance qnap has remote, audio inout, speakers, keyboard and mouse access. When it comes to the available options when it comes to the raid configuration options, synology is at a clear advantage. Oct 25, 2018 the os on the qnap nas is a great user experience and can handle most tasks you throw at it, but i have a personal soft spot for synology s dms in terms of design and functionality. Due to the california mandate shelter in place, qnap us office located in pomona california will be temporary closed for operation.
You can select the bay count that matches your required capacity and data redundancy mechanism. Those who looked at the new synology diskstation and qnap nas and said yes. I put in my own compatible drives, originally 2 x 1tb wd black, then 2 x 2tb wd red. It is based on the same realtek rtd1296 used by qnap in its ts230 unit. Qnap vs synology customer support data storage spiceworks. Need help choosing the best nas for your home or office. Get licenses for advanced features from our software store. If you are new to this kind of technology, it can be pretty confusing and it isnt helped when some nas drives arrive at very similar price points and seem near identical at a casual glance. In both cases, they use some very old, patched and somewhat poorly maintained software. I use a synology ds212j obviously for about 4 years.
One article i read compared synology to a mac and qnap to a linux box. Qnaps qts and synologys dsm are two great software options for a nas. Synology is much better with qc of their software and are generally always. Discussion in nas systems and networked home and smb software started by msvirtualguy. There is no avoiding the fact that the synology dsm and qnap qts software platform evolved and changes much, much faster than the hardware and even nas drives that are 12 years old will still. The latter is an updated model based loosely on the original ts451, and were ready to measure what. Qnap designs and delivers highquality network attached storage nas and professional network video recorder nvr solutions to users from home, soho to small, medium businesses. It is becoming increasingly hard these days not to leave a digital footprint, a trace of your whereabouts, or a few you bits and bytes of what you are doing. Synology invests heavily in its firstparty software, meaning that diskstation manager the os on the unit to put it plainly will run all those 1st. Jan 14, 2016 qnap has two new nas appliances designed for the soho market.
Jan 10, 2020 synology announced the 4bay ds420j nas at ces 2020, though the details of the unit have been public for a few months now. The desktop settinginterface of dsm os shares relatively high semblance with apples macos while qnaps qts os can be compared to windows or android. So if the main purpose of your nas is for surveillance, i would stick with synology, each software upgrade is only going to be more beneficial to you. Qnap seems to be catching up, but too slowly to meet my current needs. In both cases, however, the main attraction is the software that comes with the nas. After leaving this page, you can reach your last comparison under comparisons. Asustor, qnap, and synology introduce new nas units at ces. I found that the qnap solution is really a server that can run all types of virtual services.
You can even set up your own media server with plex, using the excellent dsm. Straight away when you compare the specifications both in terms of hardware and software of a qnap nas versus a synology, you will immediately notice that you get much better cpus and ram options in the qnap, as well as it costing less. Of course, in this qnap series, qnap makes a 16 bay and a 24 bay, and synology does not. So, syno it was and will be for the foreseeable future. Synology announced the 4bay ds420j nas at ces 2020, though the details of the unit have been public for a few months now.
Qnaps software provides more options, more room to tweak and tinker. Trying to figure out how to sync files from your pc to your nas device. Compare reset the following reference table shows the maximum capacity that can be used based on different data redundancy mechanisms. Qnap, on the other hand, is based on an operating system called the qts os. If you have any further questions about qnap products or solutions, contact customer service through the service portal. Operating system while synology nas devices are designed with the operating system, diskstation manager dsm, qnap is based on the qts os.
Dsm os desktop setting or interface has some common features, relatively, with apples macos, whereas qnaps qts operating system is comparable with android or windows. Synology the beefy qnap tvsec880 delivers better performance under heavy workloads, while the elegant synology ds2015xs shines with useful tools. My other devices which uses services provided by these nases never have an issue with synology, whether it is name resolution, ddns, dlna, smb or cloudsync features. Need support getting your files to sync with your synology nas. When you need a little more much like comparing a synology nas to qnap you should opt for qts, which can take full advantage of the more powerful hardware. Synology vs qnap compared which nas should you buy in 2019. Synology is fine for those systems where you need support, but not live. It shares many of the features and functionality of the synology counterpart, but whereas the synology dsm software hides all the technical information and restricts actions to a more stable and controlled environment, qnap and qts given you the technical information far more readily. Synology and qnap offer highend, userfriendly software that will make setting up the nas easy. Choosing a nas for the home or office shouldnt really be determined by the os unless you have a personal preference. Comparison of synology diskstation ds216j and qnap ts228.
I prefer synology because their software is very good, and is userfriendly. It is definitely after a chunk of the business now enjoyed by much higher. Qnaps other nas deviceswe like synologys dsm software a little. Synology s software is easier to use, and prettier qnap s software provides more options, more room to tweak and tinker. Synology ds220j vs qnap ts230 nas budget nas is actually quite big business. Which storage solution should i buy for personal home use. Qnap has two new nas appliances designed for the soho market. Aug 18, 2017 i have neither used drobo, nor synology. Qnap ts1685 vs synology ds3617xs battle of the nas. Feb 03, 2020 synology ds220j vs qnap ts230 nas budget nas is actually quite big business. Synology backup the different solutions nas information. Major releases like dms6 is both a welcoming update and can also confuse. Comparison of synology diskstation ds416play and qnap ts451a.